How should we respond to Nazi marches?
Should we stay home? This seems to be what the Southern Poverty Law Center (https://www.splcenter.org/) is recommending. They say that showing up at Nazi demonstrations just feeds their notoriety. They want publicity – any publicity – and if nobody shows up to counter-protest, there’s no news story there. They lose.
This would work if everyone did it. But I don’t think everyone is actually going to do that.
Should we do what some in Berkeley are planning and create alternate events celebrating diversity? This has the advantage of depriving Nazis of their audience while actually coming out and having a good time while demonstrating our values.
This is great, for those who attend, but again, I don’t think everyone is actually going to do that.
Should we counter-demonstrate peacefully? Boston was a great example – tens of thousands of counter-protesters out-massed a few hundred Nazis who were so scared they had to get into police vans to escape instead of walking through a crowd of ordinary Americans.
This would work if we knew that thousands of people would come out and surround the Nazis. But we can’t know that.
Should we come out with batons and brass knuckles and maybe even guns, and physically attack the Nazis?
It’s damn tempting.
I know that there are those who say we should not be physically violent unless the physical violence comes from the Nazis first. There are those who, as a core value, genuinely oppose violence. There are those who say it would make us look bad to those who are not activists but who don’t really sympathize with Nazis. There are those who are not able to be physically violent.
So we can’t all do that.
Clearly, all of these are going to happen. Lefties are not amenable to being told what to do. So, the trick is not to fall for the perennial downfall of the left – factionalism. We can’t denigrate those who stay home and teach their children not to hate. We can’t make fun of those who organize alternative events. We can’t disparage those who engage in peaceful demonstrations. And we can’t abandon our brothers and sisters who are willing to fight for us.